Written Argument – Mandatory Arrests for Domestic Violence

“New York law dramatically changed when the legislature amended the Criminal Procedure Law
to require the police to make arrests in domestic violence cases when there was probable cause
to do so, regardless of the wishes of the victim. Where the evidence establishes probable cause
to believe that a misdemeanor or felony was committed, the police are prohibited from even
asking the victim about whether to arrest (www.correctionhistory.com).”
Mandatory arrest laws for domestic violence continue to be controversial. There is tremendous
support for both sides of the issue. Proponents argue that mandatory arrest laws are necessary
to protect victims from their abusers. Opponents argue that these types of laws infringe on
constitutional rights such as the right to privacy. The purpose of this assignment is to test
students’ abilities to develop a logical argument for the pros and cons of mandatory arrest laws.
You will write a concise essay that effectively argues both sides of mandatory arrests. You must
follow the format below: