Evaluation Form: Presentation of Peer-Reviewed Research (or Review) Publication on PYD Topic
Topic and Title of Presentation/Article: __________________________________________________________________________________________
Authors: __________________________________________________________________________________
Each evaluation criterion listed below will be rated on a 7-point scale: 0-1.5=Poor (or not covered),
2-3.5=Acceptable, 4-5.5=Good, 6-6.5=Excellent, 7=Exemplary (+ 1 extra point)
( ) 1. Clarity and organization of presentation.
( ) 2. Accuracy of information and interpretation of findings.
( ) 3. Comprehensiveness in coverage of information.
( ) 4. Application/Examples provided (e.g., author’s website or other work, contemporary examples in the literature)
( ) 5. Synthesis and integration with related readings from that day’s course unit (or prior units)
( ) 6. Critical evaluation (by presenter) of theoretical and methodological approaches by author(s)
( ) 7. Insightfulness of discussion questions provided (required) and skills in facilitating discussion