2
MEXICAN REVOLUTION
John Antrim
History 400
November 29, 2022
Introduction
The renowned Mexican Revolution occurred between 1910 and 1920 with the protracted brutal conflict between two opposing groups. The revolution saw changing affiliations fight against each other, eventually overthrowing the 30-year tyranny in Mexico, setting the stage for creating a federal democracy. Notably, the revolution resulted from dissatisfaction with Porfirio Diaz’s aristocratic and plutocratic policies, which favored wealthy landowners and businesspeople over commoners, igniting the revolt’s flames. Ideally, The Mexican Revolution began as a reasonably modest political movement aimed at toppling the Diaz’s regime. However, it speedily grew into a substantial economic and social change that foretold much of what Mexico would go through in the 20th century. Different historians have different ideas about how this happened. It is noteworthy that scholars take different paths while addressing similar or other topics, which remains the case regarding the Mexican Revolution. Therefore, the paper evaluates different ideas concerning the Mexican process as penned down by three historians in their different beliefs, methods, and research methods they adopted in their writings.
Gonzales Michael
Gonzales explains that the Mexican Revolution resulted from displeasure by various authorities within the Mexican territory. Colonel Green championed the revolutionary ideas, transforming the conflict into a primary political scandal intending to overthrow the dictatorial rule that spanned Mexico for many years.[1] The school of thought agrees with Kathleen and Green, explaining that political and social inequalities remain the primary reason for the revolution. The protagonist pens his story through storytelling the vivid account, describing how the revolutionist captured the Cananga miners, successfully marking the initial stages of affecting the revolution in Mexico. The book sides with many scholars writing within the framework of national and political history emanating from social and political challenges.[2] The book explains that swift action from the relevant authorities did not hinder the revolutionist ideas; it was inevitable due to the atrocities subjected to the local commoners.
Cumberland Charles
Cumberland’s history charts Mexico’s path from the agony of civil war to the foundation of a new administration. The author chronologically accounts for how the revolutionist executed the consolidation of revolutionary ambitions in a magnificent statute and the rise of an energetic leadership intent on propelling Mexico into the elite countries. This book recounts the seven years of civil unrest and anarchy that followed Victoriano Huerta’s seizure of power in 1913 and examined the roots and consequences of the revolutionary principles of the 1917 constitution to provide light on the emergence of contemporary Mexico.[3] The author explains how the civil unrest led to various notable changes in modern-day Mexico. The author believed the change was inevitable in Mexico, necessitating revolution due to existing inequalities between the poor natives and a few affluent individuals who controlled the country.
According to this school of thought, the Mexican Revolution began due to a land revolution that originated from the landowners who felt left out by the settlers who had taken over their native lands. The land reforms in 1912 were inevitable due to the atrocities the formal landowners experienced in their native country.[4] The revolutionist believed that the anachronic policy undermined their social and economic well-being. The broad interest in the land reforms and economic and social problems experienced by the official landowners engineered the political and social reforms which resulted in the revolution, and administration changes, informing the formation of modern-day Mexico policy. [5] The author documents the story from the storytelling perspective, explaining how it was torn down in Mexico, resulting in the revolution. The book offers a critical account for future use and reference.
Hart, John Mason
On the other hand, Hart retells the Mexican Revolution story built on new information gathered from Mexican and American archives and scholarly publications in the most recent times. The author explores the Mexican Revolution by pursuing various American and Mexican archives materials. This piece of history reviews different Mexican labor and agrarian past in the quest to explore how the revolution began. The changes in the 19th-century social and work movement and the agrarian unrest formed the center stage and foundation of the revolution that shaped the Mexican atmosphere.[6] The book denotes that 19th-century social changes emanated from the elite classes’ alienation of the local commoners. The few elites’ control of the lower classes brought about crises and later revolutions in the 20th century. Examine the various equivale information in navigating to the Mexican Revolution.[7] It offers more profound insight into the foundation of the Mexican Revolution as a result of the labor movement revolution. The book provides more precise information religious revolution in Mexico’s world.
Conclusion
Different historians have recorded varied pieces of writings regarding the Mexican Revolution, which aim to offer an explicit knowledge of various events. At any level, one must be coherent and persuasive enough to provide a precise picture of how the situation unfolded. The three accounts provide authentic and vivid stories in regard to the Mexican Revolution worthy of study and reflection. However, Hart offers a more compelling and persuasive history concerning the topic at hand. The account centered on the foundation of the Mexican revolt before its primary occurrence in the 20th century. Although Cumberland, Green, and Kathleen and Gonzales reflect on the events and the main reasons that lead to revolutions in history, Hart offers a more persuasive account worthy of reflection and study.
Bibliography/References
Cumberland, Charles C. Mexican Revolution: The Constitutionalist Years. Vol. 9. University of Texas Press, 1972.
Hart, John Mason. Revolutionary Mexico: the coming and process of the Mexican Revolution. Univ of California Press, 1989.
Green, Anna, and Kathleen Troup. “The houses of history: A critical reader in history and theory.” In The houses of history. Manchester University Press, 2020.
[1] Green, Anna, and Kathleen Troup. “The houses of history: A critical reader in history and theory.” In The houses of history. Manchester University Press, 2020.
[2] Green, Anna, and Kathleen Troup. “The houses of history: A critical reader in history and theory.” In The houses of history. Manchester University Press, 2020.
[3] Cumberland, Charles C. Mexican Revolution: The Constitutionalist Years. Vol. 9. University of Texas Press, 1972
[4] Cumberland, Charles C. Mexican Revolution: The Constitutionalist Years. Vol. 9. University of Texas Press, 1972
[5] Ibid
[6] Hart, John Mason. Revolutionary Mexico: the coming and process of the Mexican Revolution. Univ of California Press, 1989
[7] Ibid