Comparing and contrasting is something we do almost constantly. At
the grocery store, we might decide what type of apples to buy based on
taste preferences and price. At school, we might choose a topic for an
essay based on our interest in the topic and our perception of its
difficulty. At work, we might choose which candidate to hire for a
position based on experience, educational background, and relevant
skills. In each case, whether it is apples, essays, or future
colleagues, we are using compare and contrast skills to help us to make a
choice.
The essay you will begin writing this week and complete in Week 4 is
inspired by Chapter 8: Comparing and Contrasting—Computers and
Technology. Computers and technology influence every aspect of our daily
lives, both at home and at work. Here are a few possible topics for
your compare/contrast essay.
Working from home versus working from the office
Virtual relationships versus in-person relationships
E-sports versus “real” sports
Free software versus proprietary software
Attending college online versus attending in person
Autonomous vehicles versus conventional vehicles
Cloud computing versus on-site computing
Other topics are possible, but please consult your instructor if you would like to choose a topic not on this list.
On the other hand, please avoid topics that focus on simple preferences, such as the following.
Apple versus Samsung
Android versus IOS
XBox versus PlayStation
Any video game versus any other video game
Toaster versus toaster (see below!)
Compare/contrast essays are typically formatted in either a block
pattern or a point-by-point pattern. For the sake of example, let’s
pretend we are writing a compare/contrast essay about two toasters—a
very dull topic! Here is how the essay might be organized in the block
pattern.
Super Toaster
A. Features
B. Convenience
C. Reliability
Toaster Max
A. Features
B. Convenience
C. Reliability
Summary Analysis and Recommendation (Which toaster is better?)
On the other hand, here is how it could be organized in the point-by-point pattern.
Features
A. Super Toaster
B. Toaster Max
Convenience
A. Super Toaster
B. Toaster Max
Reliability
A. Super Toaster
B. Toaster Max
Summary Analysis and Recommendation (Which toaster is better?)
The block approach and point-by-point approach are both acceptable
essay formats. In general, the block format is probably a bit easier to
write, and the point-by-point format allows for greater precision.
Ultimately it is up to you to decide which format is better for your
topic.
For additional tips and advice on writing a comparison/contrast
essay, please see the Assignment Connection within the Week 3 Lesson.
Research Requirements
For this essay, you will need to cite at least two high-quality
sources that consider contrasting points of view. For example, if you
choose to compare and contrast working from home versus working from the
office, you will need to find sources that focus on the benefits and
drawbacks of working from home as well as the benefits and drawbacks of
working from the office. Remember that each source listed in your
references list must be cited in text, and that each source cited in
text must be listed in your references.
Successful assignments will
choose an appropriate topic;
feature an introduction explaining the purpose and scope of the essay and include a clear thesis statement;
identify appropriate criteria to base the comparison and contrast upon;
conclude with an overall assessment;
be typed and submitted as a Microsoft Word document (.docx), with 12-point font;
include a seventh edition APA-style cover page;
be three to four double-spaced pages (750–1,000 words), not including the title page; and
be submitted for grading.
The assignment rubric is shown below.
Category
Points
Criteria
Introduction and Thesis
20
It clearly states the subject of the compare and contrast and the criteria upon which the discussion will be based.
Organization
30
The essay is organized according to either block format or
point-by-point format. The essay is divided into paragraphs in a logical
fashion. Transition phrases are used effectively.
Development
50
The essay features a well-developed discussion based on the chosen
criteria. The essay identifies the most important points of similarity
and difference and explains why they are important. The essay meets or
exceeds the minimum length requirement.
Research
30
The essay includes APA style in-text references to at least two
relevant, high-quality sources. The essay includes a correctly formatted
references list.
Style and Mechanics
10
The voice of the writer is clear, distinct, and appropriate. The
writer’s message is clearly communicated with appropriate spelling and
use of grammar and punctuation. Errors do not significantly interfere
with meaning.
Total
140
The assignment meets or exceeds the above criteria.